snail eating fish

chris098 via PetKB.com · Joined: 07 Jan 2008 Posts: 6

thank you all for your coments,is there a snail eating fish that is safe to
keep with new born fry,

--
Message posted via PetKB.com
http://www.petkb.com/Uwe/Forums.aspx/freshwater/200802/1

Archived from group: rec>aquaria>freshwater>misc

Tynk · Joined: 16 Aug 2007 Posts: 200

On Feb 23, 11:51ï¿½am, "chris098 via PetKB.com" wrote:
> thank you all for your coments,is there a snail eating fish that is safe to
> keep with new born fry,
>
> --
> Message posted via PetKB.comhttp://www.petkb.com/Uwe/Forums.aspx/freshwater/200802/1

You really need to add more info.
What size tank are we talking about?
What type of snails?
What type of fry, and how large are they?
Parents in with them?
Temp of the tank, and whether it's a soft/ acidic tank or hard/
alkaline?

chris098 via PetKB.com · Joined: 07 Jan 2008 Posts: 6

Tynk wrote:
>> thank you all for your coments,is there a snail eating fish that is safe to
>> keep with new born fry,
>>
>> --
>> Message posted via PetKB.comhttp://www.petkb.com/Uwe/Forums.aspx/freshwater/200802/1
>
>You really need to add more info.
>What size tank are we talking about?
>What type of snails?
>What type of fry, and how large are they?
>Parents in with them?
>Temp of the tank, and whether it's a soft/ acidic tank or hard/
>alkaline?
the tank is 30lt,not sure on the type of snails ,but there is two types;the
fish in the tank are guppys,and there own fry are in with them,temp 26, water
hard

--
Message posted via http://www.petkb.com

Rain Fan Dominical, CR · Joined: 17 Feb 2008 Posts: 8

On Feb 24, 1:03 pm, "chris098 via PetKB.com" wrote:
> Tynk wrote:
> >> thank you all for your coments,is there a snail eating fish that is safe to
> >> keep with new born fry,
>
> >> --
> >> Message posted via PetKB.comhttp://www.petkb.com/Uwe/Forums.aspx/freshwater/200802/1
>
> >You really need to add more info.
> >What size tank are we talking about?
> >What type of snails?
> >What type of fry, and how large are they?
> >Parents in with them?
> >Temp of the tank, and whether it's a soft/ acidic tank or hard/
> >alkaline?
>
> the tank is 30lt,not sure on the type of snails ,but there is two types;the
> fish in the tank are guppys,and there own fry are in with them,temp 26, water
> hard
>
> --
> Message posted viahttp://www.petkb.com

I have always prefered to have snails even if they are small snails
and lotas of them in any fry tank as they helped clean up the mess
that fry tanks make as compared to other type tanks.....Clown loaches
will eradicate the snails, but so will a slice of zuchinni squash
floating in the water and netted out when all the snails accumulate on
it. May take a few days but its still a very effectived means of
elinminating a lot of snails. Of course you probbaly will be dealing
with egg masses on tank glass etc as well as inside the fitler so
arbitrarily getting rid of snails is not such a simple matter, and
will take time.

Tynk · Joined: 20 Jan 2008 Posts: 3

On Feb 25, 12:42 pm, "chris098 via PetKB.com" wrote:
> Rain Fan Dominical, CR wrote:
>
>
>
> >> >> thank you all for your coments,is there a snail eating fish that is safe to
> >> >> keep with new born fry,
> >[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> >> --
> >> Message posted viahttp://www.petkb.com
>
> >I have always prefered to have snails even if they are small snails
> >and lotas of them in any fry tank as they helped clean up the mess
> >that fry tanks make as compared to other type tanks.....Clown loaches
> >will eradicate the snails, but so will a slice of zuchinni squash
> >floating in the water and netted out when all the snails accumulate on
> >it. May take a few days but its still a very effectived means of
> >elinminating a lot of snails. Of course you probbaly will be dealing
> >with egg masses on tank glass etc as well as inside the fitler so
> >arbitrarily getting rid of snails is not such a simple matter, and
> >will take time.
>
> like you i don't want to get rid of all snails,i just need to keep there
> numbers in check
>
> --
> Message posted via PetKB.comhttp://www.petkb.com/Uwe/Forums.aspx/freshwater/200802/1- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

Then its so much better to use a slice of zuchinni squash or a piece
of lettuce floatinmg in the tank and removed with snails on it. YOU
can control what you yourself harvests but have no real control over
what a fish may consume or kill. Just slice a pice of zuchinni squash
into silices about 1/4" thick, and place in the tank early evening,
before lights out. Next morning use a net to scoop out zuchinni slice
and rinse it off under runing water which wil wash off snails inthe
process.....You can toss it in the tank all day long too, but you wind
up feding the snails and therefore they may not be as good as a clean
up crew as they could be since they found easy food to get instead of
hunting for scraps as usual. The squash method works and works good. I
have heard some folks use sliced cucumbers too.

chris098 via PetKB.com · Joined: 07 Jan 2008 Posts: 6

Rain Fan Dominical, CR wrote:
>> >> thank you all for your coments,is there a snail eating fish that is safe to
>> >> keep with new born fry,
>[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
>> --
>> Message posted viahttp://www.petkb.com
>
>I have always prefered to have snails even if they are small snails
>and lotas of them in any fry tank as they helped clean up the mess
>that fry tanks make as compared to other type tanks.....Clown loaches
>will eradicate the snails, but so will a slice of zuchinni squash
>floating in the water and netted out when all the snails accumulate on
>it. May take a few days but its still a very effectived means of
>elinminating a lot of snails. Of course you probbaly will be dealing
>with egg masses on tank glass etc as well as inside the fitler so
>arbitrarily getting rid of snails is not such a simple matter, and
>will take time.
like you i don't want to get rid of all snails,i just need to keep there
numbers in check

--
Message posted via PetKB.com
http://www.petkb.com/Uwe/Forums.aspx/freshwater/200802/1